Personal Injury Lawyer Wilmington NC | Flexner Houser Injury Law

Pros and Cons of an Out-of-Court Settlement for a Personal Injury Case

An out-of-court settlement is an agreement between two parties to resolve a dispute without going to trial. This type of settlement is often used in civil cases, such as personal injury or contract disputes. The parties involved will work together to reach an agreement that is satisfactory to both sides. Once the terms of the settlement are agreed upon, they will be put in writing and signed by both parties.

There are many factors to consider when deciding whether to settle a personal injury case out of court or take it to trial. Here are some pros and cons of each option to help you make a decision.

Pros of an Out-of-Court Settlement for a North Carolina Personal Injury Case

There are many reasons people consider an out-of-court settlement for their North Carolina personal injury case. Here are some of the pros: 

i. You Can Avoid the Stress of a Trial: When you are injured in an accident, you may be able to avoid the stress of a trial by settling your case out of court. By settling your case out of court, you can avoid having to relive the accident in front of a judge and jury.

ii. Save Time and Money: An out-of-court settlement means that the parties involved in the dispute come to an agreement without having to go through the formal process of litigation. This can be a cheaper and faster option than going to court, which could be costly and time-consuming.

iii. You Have a Greater Certainty of Outcome: When a personal injury case is settled out of court, the parties involved have a greater certainty of outcome. The chance of success is increased because the negotiation process is less adversarial than litigation. This means that they can be more certain of what the final outcome of the case will be, and they can plan accordingly. 

iv. You Maintain Some Level of Control Over the Process: An out-of-court settlement puts you in the driver’s seat, so to speak, and allows you to negotiate a fair resolution with the at-fault party. Unlike with many court judgments, if you are not happy with an out-of-court settlement offer, you can walk away from the negotiation and take your chances in court.

v. You Can Keep the Case Private: An out-of-court personal injury settlement allows the parties to keep the case private. This is a pro because it allows the parties to avoid public scrutiny and the media attention that can accompany a court case. This can be beneficial for both parties, as they may not want their personal information to be available to everyone. Additionally, it can help to protect the victim’s reputation.

Cons of an Out-of-Court Settlement for a North Carolina Personal Injury Case

There are a few disadvantages to settling a personal injury case without going to court. They are:

i. The Insurer May Take Advantage of the Injured Party: An out-of-court personal injury settlement may not be in the best interest of the injured party. The insurer may take advantage of the injured party by offering a low settlement amount. The injured party may be unaware of the true value of their claim and accept the low offer.

ii. The Terms of the Settlement May Be Unfair: In continuation of point (i) above, you will likely have to sign away your right to sue in the future, which could prevent you from receiving future full compensation for your injuries. 

iii. The Other Side Might Not Stick to the Agreement: One downside is that the other side might not stick to the agreement. This is especially true if you signed an agreement with the other party in the absence of a skilled personal injury attorney. If they fail to make the promised payments, you’ll have to go back to court and try to enforce the settlement. This can be time-consuming and expensive. It may also be an uphill battle as you may have unwittingly signed terms that you originally might not have agreed to.

Weighing the Pros and Cons of an Out-of-Court Settlement

In conclusion, whether or not to accept an out-of-court settlement for a personal injury case in North Carolina is sometimes a difficult decision to make. There are pros and cons to taking this route, and ultimately it is up to the individual to decide what is best for them. If you are considering an out-of-court settlement, be sure to consult with an experienced personal injury attorney who can help you understand all of your options and make the best decision for your case.

Scroll to Top